Stacy Keach, Star of Fat City and Mike Hammer, Dies at 85

Stacy Keach, the actor with the gravel voice and the most famous mustache in 1980s television, died on Tuesday, November 10, at his family home in Magdalenka, Poland. He was 85. His wife, Malgosia Tomassi Keach, confirmed his death to The Hollywood Reporter, saying he had been living with a serious heart condition and heart failure.

Most of the headlines will say "Mike Hammer," and fair enough. Keach played Mickey Spillane's hard-boiled private eye through the 1980s and into the '90s, and for a whole generation he was the trench coat and the fedora. But if Hammer is all you know, you're missing the best of him.

Start with Fat City

In 1972, John Huston cast Keach as Billy Tully, a washed-up boxer in Stockton, California, trying to talk himself into one more comeback. Jeff Bridges plays the kid Tully half-mentors and half-envies. It's one of the saddest, most clear-eyed American films of the decade: no big fight finale, no redemption arc, just people drifting through cheap bars and day-labour shifts and telling themselves next week will be different. Keach doesn't play Tully as a tragic hero. He plays him as a guy who's very good at not noticing his own decline, which is much harder to watch, and much better.

[AFFILIATE: Fat City (1972) on Blu-ray — the film this post argues is his best]

The range nobody talks about

Look at the rest of the filmography and the man is all over the map. He was Doc Holliday in Doc (1971) and Frank James in The Long Riders (1980), a western he also co-wrote and executive produced, starring opposite his brother James as Jesse. He was Sgt. Stedenko, the hapless narcotics cop chasing Cheech and Chong in Up in Smoke (1978). He was Cameron Alexander, the calm, reasonable-sounding white supremacist recruiter in American History X (1998), a role that's frightening precisely because he never raises his voice. And he was Ed Pegram, the small-town bully in Alexander Payne's Nebraska (2013).

On TV he followed Hammer with the warden in Prison Break, the alcoholic dad in Titus, and a cardinal on Blue Bloods. He won a Golden Globe playing Ernest Hemingway in the 1988 miniseries Hemingway.

Keach as Mike Hammer in Murder Me, Murder You (1983). Columbia Pictures Television press photo, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Featured photo: Bernard Gotfryd, 1969, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

The stage was home base

Keach trained at UC Berkeley, the Yale School of Drama and, as a Fulbright scholar, at LAMDA in London. Theatre people knew him as a serious classical actor long before TV made him famous. He earned a Tony nomination for Indians (1970), played Hamlet at the Delacorte Theater in Central Park in 1972, and came back to Shakespeare decades later with King Lear. He also toured the U.S. as Richard Nixon in Frost/Nixon. That training is why his villains and losers never feel like caricatures. He built them from the inside.

He was born with a cleft lip, and the famous mustache was partly there to cover the surgical scars. He became a long-time advocate for cleft palate charities. It's a small detail, but it says something about a career built on owning what made him different.

Keach is survived by his wife, his two children, and his brother James Keach, an actor and director.

If you want to honour him this weekend, skip the Hammer reruns for one night and put on Fat City.

Previous
Previous

Jonathan Bailey and Bill Nighy Will Play Bill Hayes and Oliver Sacks in Insomniac City

Next
Next

Constantine Probably Isn’t Happening: What Gunn’s Exit Means for DC’s Slate