Haymitch Abernathy was always the most interesting person in Panem who wasn't Katniss. A drunk who survived the Games and spent the rest of his life paying for it is a better premise than most franchises get. Now that the reviews for The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping are in, the verdict is pretty clear: the character holds up. The movie around him is another story.
The numbers
The review embargo lifted on November 17, three days before the film opens on November 20. As of this writing the Rotten Tomatoes score is hovering around 70 percent, and it has moved between 69 and 72 as reviews keep landing. Metacritic sits at 56, which is the site's "mixed or average" range.
For context, here's the franchise on Rotten Tomatoes:
The Hunger Games (2012): 85%
Catching Fire (2013): 90%
Mockingjay Part 1 (2014): 70%
Mockingjay Part 2 (2015): 70%
The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes (2023): 64%
So Sunrise lands right in Mockingjay territory. It's not a disaster and it's not a return to Catching Fire form either.
What critics like: Joseph Zada
The most consistent praise goes to Joseph Zada, the young Australian actor playing Haymitch at 16, when he's reaped for the 50th Games, the Second Quarter Quell. David Rooney at The Hollywood Reporter says Zada brings "tenacity, kindness and heartrending vulnerability" to the role. That matters, because Suzanne Collins' novel only works if you believe the kid who walks into the arena could become the wreck Woody Harrelson played.
The supporting cast is stacked: Ralph Fiennes as President Snow, Jesse Plemons as Plutarch Heavensbee, Elle Fanning as a young Effie Trinket, Kieran Culkin as Caesar Flickerman, plus Mckenna Grace, Maya Hawke, Kelvin Harrison Jr., Lili Taylor and Glenn Close.
Ralph Fiennes plays President Snow. Photo: Steve Disenhof / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Featured image: Francis Lawrence, photo by Gage Skidmore / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0.
What they don't: déjà vu
The complaints mostly come back to one idea: we've seen this movie. Owen Gleiberman at Variety gave it a fresh review but still called it "meandering and more than a bit thin." Empire's Olly Richards notes how closely it tracks the beats of the earlier films, which were "much better the first time." Brandon Yu at The New York Times found it "both bloated and limited," and The Guardian's Peter Bradshaw was harsher still, saying it has no "authentic reason to exist." Bradshaw also pointed at the runtime, a reported 158 minutes.
That's the trap of a prequel built on a Games. The arena structure that made the first film electric is now a template, and a template is hard to make dangerous. Francis Lawrence, back for his fifth film in the series, knows how to stage it. The question is whether a familiar structure can still surprise anyone.
[AFFILIATE: Sunrise on the Reaping by Suzanne Collins (novel), for readers who want Haymitch's full story before or after the film]
None of this is likely to hurt the opening. Presales are reported as strong, and projections sit somewhere between $105 and $120 million domestic, far above Ballad's $44 million debut. Mixed reviews have never stopped this audience before. If you're going, go for Zada. Just don't expect the arena to feel new.

